Jefferies Recalibrates Their View on First Solar — What Does It Mean for Investors Now?

The solar energy sector has long been viewed as a playground for growth investors, synonymous with innovation and the global energy transition. At the heart of this sector is First Solar, Inc. (FSLR), a leading U.S.-based manufacturer of solar panels specializing in advanced thin-film photovoltaic (PV) modules. The company’s business model is built on vertically integrated manufacturing, with a global footprint and a focus on utility-scale solar projects. Until recently, First Solar was seen as one of the sector's most resilient names, benefitting from supportive policy, a robust order backlog, and manufacturing scale.

However, a significant shift occurred today as Jefferies, a top-tier Wall Street research firm, downgraded First Solar from “Buy” to “Hold” and set its price target at $127—the same as the stock’s current trading price. For self-directed investors, this move warrants a deeper look. Analyst upgrades and downgrades are critical signals: they often reflect not just hard data, but also the analyst’s conviction, access to industry checks, and forward-looking assessments that can precede broader market moves.

Key Takeaways:

  • Potential Upside is Neutral: With Jefferies’ new $127 price target matching the current price, the firm signals limited near-term upside for First Solar.

  • Sharp Downward Price Move: First Solar’s stock dropped 7.4% today after disappointing Q1 earnings and guidance cuts, aligning with Jefferies’ more cautious stance.

  • News-Driven Volatility: The downgrade follows a wave of negative headlines—missed revenue/earnings, reduced annual guidance, and warnings about tariffs’ impact.

  • Technical Weakness & Sentiment: The stock is hovering near its 12-month lows, with a neutral RSI and below-trend moving averages, reflecting deteriorating momentum.

  • Jefferies’ Influence: As a large, influential firm with deep cleantech expertise, Jefferies’ shift from Buy to Hold carries weight—especially after the company’s earnings stumble.

Jefferies’ Downgrade: Context and Analyst Confidence

Understanding the Analyst’s Perspective

Jefferies is a highly respected firm in equity research, particularly in the industrials and renewables sectors. Their decision to downgrade First Solar from “Buy” to “Hold” is not taken lightly. This change follows a series of concerning developments:

  • Q1 2025 Earnings Miss: First Solar missed both revenue and earnings expectations, with a notable shortfall in its core utility-scale business.

  • Guidance Cut: Management lowered its annual sales and profit outlook, citing policy uncertainty, softer demand, and margin pressures.

  • Tariff Headwinds: CEO Mark Widmar highlighted that new Trump administration tariffs pose a “significant economic headwind,” further complicating the near-term outlook.

Jefferies’ downgrade aligns with these realities, signaling a cautious stance until visibility improves. The price target reset at $127 (matching the current close) suggests Jefferies sees limited room for outperformance in the short term. Given Jefferies’ reputation for rigorous channel checks and sector expertise, this move is a strong vote of no confidence in First Solar’s near-term catalysts.

“First Solar’s growth runway remains, but near-term clouds obscure the view. We step to the sidelines pending more clarity on policy and execution.”
— Jefferies Research Note, April 30, 2025

Stock and Financial Performance: A Deepening Slide

Quantifying the Recent Downturn

First Solar’s shares are now trading at $127, down 7.4% today, following a sharp post-earnings selloff. Over the last 12 months, the stock has swung from a high of $306.77 to a recent low of $116.56. The sentiment has been negative, with more down days than up days (135 vs. 112), and the 20-day EMA ($131.92) and SMA ($130.28) both sit above the current price, underlining technical weakness.

Recent Financials (Q1 2025):

  • Revenue: Missed estimates (exact figures undisclosed, but below consensus)

  • Earnings: Fell short of analyst targets

  • Guidance: Lowered for FY25

  • Volume: Spiked on the selloff (over 8.6M shares traded today, well above average)

These data points paint a picture of a company in transition, wrestling with both internal execution challenges and external policy risk.

Technical Overview: Support or More Downside?

  • RSI: 48.25 (neutral, but trending down)

  • Bollinger Bands: Current price near lower band ($118.12), suggesting oversold territory but no immediate reversal signal

  • Average Daily Volatility: 9.33%, highlighting the potential for big swings

Potential Upside (or Lack Thereof):

With the price target now set at $127—the exact market price—Jefferies sees no potential upside in the near term. This is a classic “wait-and-see” call, signaling to investors that the risk/reward is currently balanced, with headwinds equaling opportunities. For those holding First Solar, this is a clear message to temper expectations and monitor for further developments.

Recent News and Its Impact: Sentiment Shift in Real Time

The downgrade from Jefferies comes amid a rapid deterioration in sentiment, as reflected in recent headlines:

These headlines have clearly contributed to the stock’s sharp drop and explain Jefferies’ more cautious outlook.

Sector Context: Solar’s Policy-Driven Crossroads

First Solar’s downgrade cannot be viewed in isolation. The solar sector is now navigating a complex policy environment, with tariffs and trade disputes adding uncertainty to what was once a straightforward growth narrative. While long-term demand for renewables remains robust, near-term volatility is being driven by shifting government priorities and global trade tensions.

What Should Investors Watch Now?

  • Policy Developments: Any changes to tariffs or renewable incentives could materially shift First Solar’s outlook.

  • Order Backlog and Execution: Watch for updates on project wins, backlog conversion, and cost controls.

  • Technical Levels: The $116–$130 range is now critical support. Further weakness could see the stock test new multi-year lows.

  • Peer Valuations: As the sector re-rates, keep an eye on how First Solar’s valuation compares to other leading solar names.

Conclusion: Caution Is the Watchword, but Don’t Write Off Solar

Jefferies’ downgrade of First Solar to Hold, with a price target that offers no upside to current levels, is a clear signal: the easy gains are gone for now, and investors must navigate a period of heightened uncertainty. For sophisticated investors, this is a time for vigilance—monitoring not just company execution, but also the broader policy and macro landscape that will define solar’s next move.

While First Solar’s long-term prospects as a leader in the energy transition remain intact, this downgrade is a reminder that even the sector’s brightest stars can face bouts of darkness. Stay nimble, stay informed, and be ready to act when the clouds begin to clear.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber?
Sign in

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber?
Sign in