A Downgrade That Demands Attention: Cleveland-Cliffs Faces New Analyst Scrutiny

Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. (CLF), a major force in the U.S. steel and mining sector, has been thrust into the spotlight as Jefferies, a top-tier global investment bank, downgraded the stock from "Buy" to "Hold" with a revised price target of $6. This shift comes amidst a period of surging legal scrutiny, heightened market volatility, and mounting questions about the company’s turnaround prospects. Understanding the rationale and potential implications of this downgrade is critical in a landscape where analyst sentiment can meaningfully sway both near-term price action and long-term confidence.

Key Takeaways:

  • Jefferies Downgrade: Jefferies, a highly influential analyst firm, shifted its rating on Cleveland-Cliffs from "Buy" to "Hold," setting a new price target of $6 (current price: $5.96), signaling limited upside potential in the near term.

  • Stock Near Lows: The stock is trading near its 52-week lows, with significant downward momentum and a notably low RSI, reflecting oversold technical conditions.

  • Legal Investigations Intensify: Recent news highlights ongoing securities investigations by multiple law firms, adding uncertainty and potential downside risk for shareholders.

  • Mixed Sentiment and Weak Price Action: With more down days than up days across the last year, sentiment remains negative, as reflected in both technical and volume indicators.

  • Turnaround Narrative Questioned: Despite high-profile defenses of the company’s strategy, analyst skepticism is growing regarding the credibility and timing of any potential recovery.

Unpacking the Downgrade: Analyst Perspective and Sector Dynamics

Jefferies’ Call: More Than a Routine Downgrade

Jefferies’ downgrade of Cleveland-Cliffs is notable not only for the firm’s stature—consistently ranked among the most influential U.S. and global equity research houses—but also for the timing. The shift from "Buy" to "Hold" with a price target of $6—just above the current trading price—reflects a view that risk/reward is now balanced at best. Jefferies’ analysts are known for their deep sector expertise in industrials and materials, lending significant weight to this action.

Historically, a Jefferies rating change can catalyze notable institutional flows, particularly when the firm’s outlook diverges from the prevailing market narrative. Here, the downgrade comes as Cleveland-Cliffs faces intensifying legal scrutiny and a weakening technical profile, both of which can be self-reinforcing in a market susceptible to risk-off sentiment.

"Jefferies’ downgrade signals a critical reassessment of near-term catalysts. Their track record in the steel and mining sector means this call won’t be ignored by institutional allocators." — DeepStreet

Cleveland-Cliffs: A Business at the Crossroads

Cleveland-Cliffs operates as a vertically integrated steel and iron ore producer, with a business model spanning mining, pelletizing, and steelmaking. The company’s fortunes are closely tied to U.S. industrial cycles, infrastructure spending, and commodity price dynamics. Over the past year, CLF’s share price has dropped precipitously from a high of $17.41 to recent lows near $5.93, underperforming both sector peers and broader equity indices.

Despite public defenses of the company’s turnaround plan—most notably by Jim Lebenthal on CNBC, who argued that the stock is “undervalued” and has “a credible turnaround plan”—the market has yet to reward these efforts. The technical setup further underscores investor skepticism, with the stock registering more down than up days, depressed average daily volume, and an RSI below 30, typically a sign of oversold conditions but also of caution.

Stock Price and Technical Trends: Is There a Silver Lining?

  • Current Price: $5.96 (as of pre-market, 2025-05-29)

  • Jefferies Target: $6.00 (potential upside: negligible at less than 1%)

  • 52-Week Range: $5.93 (low) to $17.41 (high)

  • Volume & Volatility: Recent sessions have seen low volume, with average daily volatility around 0.5%, suggesting subdued trading interest.

  • Technical Indicators:

    • RSI at 29.4: Firmly in oversold territory, but no clear reversal signals.

    • SMA/EMA (20-day): Both above current price, highlighting persistent downward momentum.

    • Bollinger Bands: Price hugging the lower band, reinforcing a bearish bias.

The stock’s weak technicals are mirrored by fundamental headwinds. The company’s weighted average price over the last year is $10.71, and the persistent inability to break through short-term moving averages further dampens bullish enthusiasm.

Legal Uncertainty and Newsflow: A Double-Edged Sword

Recent headlines have further clouded the outlook for Cleveland-Cliffs:

While some market voices defend the company’s long-term prospects, the legal overhang is clearly spooking investors. These investigations, if they escalate, could result in costly settlements or distract management from executing on strategic initiatives, amplifying downside risk.

"The firm’s ongoing investigation concerns whether Cleveland-Cliffs and/or certain of its officers have violated the federal securities laws and/or engaged in other unlawful business practices." — GlobeNewsWire

Analyst Confidence and the Weight of the Downgrade

Jefferies’ downgrade is not merely a reflection of current price action but also a clear signal that the catalyst-rich narrative around Cleveland-Cliffs is faltering. With the price target barely above the market, Jefferies is effectively telegraphing skepticism about any near-term bounce, despite technically oversold conditions. Given Jefferies’ reputation for rigorous sector coverage and its influence among institutional clients, this call may lead to further derisking by funds previously betting on a turnaround.

Notably, the downgrade aligns with a negative sentiment ratio (more down days than up), weak price momentum, and legal headlines—all of which create a challenging environment for any immediate recovery.

What Does the Downgrade Mean for Investors?

  • Potential Upside: At current levels, the upside to Jefferies’ $6.00 target is less than 1%, indicating that, in their view, most of the near-term good news is already priced in.

  • Downside Risks: Legal and regulatory overhangs, as well as continued technical weakness, could drive the stock lower if negative developments persist.

  • Sector Context: The U.S. steel industry is cyclical, sensitive to both economic data and policy changes. At a time when macroeconomic uncertainty remains elevated, stocks like CLF with high operating leverage and significant legal distractions may continue to underperform.

  • Turnaround Versus Value Trap: While some contrarians view the stock as a deep value play given its historical price and business model, the downgrade underscores that the burden of proof is now on management to demonstrate tangible progress.

Conclusion: A Stock at an Inflection Point

Cleveland-Cliffs now stands at a precarious juncture. With Jefferies stepping back from its bullish stance and price action reflecting deep investor skepticism, the path forward is fraught with risk. The combination of legal uncertainty, technical weakness, and analyst caution warrants a measured, data-driven approach. Until the company can resolve its legal distractions and reignite operational momentum, Cleveland-Cliffs is likely to remain a battleground stock, with little near-term upside and meaningful headline risk.

As always, staying attuned to both fundamental developments and analyst sentiment will be crucial for those navigating this volatile corner of the market.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber?
Sign in